Improved forage management impacts on soil organic C and S depth distribution and surface residue accumulation could be large, but detailed temporal data are not available. We evaluated the factorial combination of three levels of N fertilization [inorganic, crimson clover (Trifolium incarnatum L.) cover crop plus inorganic, and broiler litter] and four levels of harvest strategy (unharvested, low grazing pressure, high grazing pressure, and hayed monthly) on soil bulk density, soil organic C, and total S, and surface residue C and S during the first 5 yr of 'Coastal' bermudagrass [Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers.] management. Soil bulk density of the 0- to 6-cm depth responded very little to management, but across treatments it decreased 0.06 Mg m-3 yr-1 due to increasing soil organic matter with time. Soil organic C did not respond significantly to fertilization strategy during the 5 yr, but total S of the 0- to 6-cm depth was greater under broiler litter than under other fertilization strategies at the end of 3, 4, and 5 yr. Low and high grazing pressure were similar in their effect on soil organic C accumulation, averaging 140 g m-2 yr-1. Most of the net change in soil organic C occurred in the 0- to 2-cm depth. Soil under unharvested and hayed management accumulated organic C at rates less than one-half of those observed under cattle grazing. Cattle grazing shunted C more directly from forage to the soil, which contributed to greater sequestration of soil organic C than with haying or unharvested management.