Straw amendment is a common practice for improving the fertility of rice field soils, but it also enhances production of the greenhouse gas methane. To quantify carbon flux partitioning and priming effects due to straw amendment, we measured delta C-13 in CH4 and CH4 precursors produced in anoxic slurries of soil from Italy, China and Thailand after addition of straw from either rice (C3 plant) or maize plants (C4 plant), which have different delta C-13 signatures. The delta C-13 values of the CH4, acetate and CO2 produced were similar when expressed as the difference to the delta C-13 value of the straw applied. These results indicated that the C-13-isotopic fractionation involved in methanogenic decomposition was similar for rice straw and maize straw. However, measurement of CH4 produced in soil without or with straw showed that isotopic fractionation during methanogenic degradation of straw was smaller than during degradation of soil organic matter. Isotopic fractionation during hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis, measured in the presence of methyl fluoride, with straw was also smaller than with soil organic matter. The results show that C-13-isotopic analysis after application of rice straw and maize straw is a convenient approach for quantifying carbon flux partitioning during methanogenic degradation of straw and soil organic matter. In our experiments, straw degradation accounted for most of the CH4 production and caused a negative priming effect on the methanogenic degradation of soil organic matter. (c) 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
