Citation Information

  • Title : Nitrous oxide emissions respond differently to mineral and organic Nitrogen sources in contrasting soil types.
  • Source : Journal of Environmental Quality
  • Publisher : American Society of Agronomy
  • Volume : 41
  • Issue : 2
  • Pages : 427-435
  • Year : 2012
  • DOI : 10.2134/jeq2011.0261 ER
  • ISBN : 0047-2425
  • Document Type : Journal Article
  • Language : English
  • Authors:
    • Angers, D. A.
    • Rochette, P.
    • Chantigny, M. H.
    • Pelster, D. E.
    • Rieux, C.
    • Vanasse, A.
  • Climates: Warm summer continental/Hemiboreal (Dsb, Dfb, Dwb).
  • Cropping Systems: Wheat.
  • Countries: Canada.

Summary

The use of various animal manures for nitrogen (N) fertilization is often viewed as a viable replacement for mineral N fertilizers. However, the impacts of amendment type on N 2O production may vary. In this study, N 2O emissions were measured for 2 yr on two soil types with contrasting texture and carbon (C) content under a cool, humid climate. Treatments consisted of a no-N control, calcium ammonium nitrate, poultry manure, liquid cattle manure, or liquid swine manure. The N sources were surface applied and immediately incorporated at 90 kg N ha -1 before seeding of spring wheat ( Triticum aestivum L.). Cumulative N 2O-N emissions from the silty clay ranged from 2.2 to 8.3 kg ha -1 yr -1 and were slightly lower in the control than in the fertilized plots ( P=0.067). The 2-yr mean N 2O emission factors ranged from 2.0 to 4.4% of added N, with no difference among N sources. Emissions of N 2O from the sandy loam soil ranged from 0.3 to 2.2 kg N 2O-N ha -1 yr -1, with higher emissions with organic than mineral N sources ( P=0.015) and the greatest emissions with poultry manure ( P<0.001). The N 2O emission factor from plots amended with poultry manure was 1.8%, more than double that of the other treatments (0.3-0.9%), likely because of its high C content. On the silty clay, the yield-based N 2O emissions (g N 2O-N kg -1 grain yield N) were similar between treatments, whereas on the sandy loam, they were greatest when amended with poultry manure. Our findings suggest that, compared with mineral N sources, manure application only increases soil N 2O flux in soils with low C content.

Full Text Link